Latin America is one of the most dangerous regions in the world, and according to some international reports, in fact tops the list. Just a few weeks ago, Gallup, a US-based research company, released a worldwide survey on safety perception that showed that Venezuelans are the people least likely to feel safe.
Eleven countries in the ‘top 30′ of Gallup’s ranking – which includes 134 countries – are Latin American, a worrying number that shows the notorious reputation this region has.
Venezuela’s crime problems are among the worst in Latin America, as could be seen in the last presidential election, when both candidates made this issue a key focus of the campaign. Though the Venezuelan government no longer releases official crime statistics, it is well known that the country continues to struggle with high rates of murder, kidnapping, and drug trafficking. In 2012, 40% of Venezuelans told Gallup there were illicit drug trafficking or sales in their area, and 10% said they had had a relative or close friend murdered in the past 12 months. Low ratings on Gallup’s physical security question are nothing new in Venezuela. Indeed, since 2008, less than one third of Venezuelans have said they feel safe walking in their neighbourhood alone at night.
Whilst Venezuela is a conspicuos example of a country with alarmingly high crime rates, it is not alone in Latin America. Hard data shows that high homicide rates are a constant in the region, especially in countries with serious and on-going drug trafficking and gang problems such as Mexico and Honduras.

San Pedro Sula, Honduras; the most dangerous city in the world (photo courtesy of Wikipedia)
The Most Dangerous Cities in the World
‘Seguridad, Justicia y Paz’ (Security, Justice and Peace), also referred to as the Citizens’ Council for Public Security and Criminal Justice, is a civil society organisation from Mexico that emerged in July 2002. Its members describe it as “a non-partisan network, secular and independent.” At the end of 2012, they published a study which ranked the 50 most dangerous cities in the world, based on homicide rates.
While homicides are far from being the only crime there is, they are widely used to measure crime rates because, unlike other types of offenses such as theft or rape, are generally reported to the authoritites. Homicide rate is considered an imperfect index for measuring insecurity and violence.
The report shows that three out of the ten most violent cities in the world are Mexican, while 47 of the 50 most violent cities are located in the Americas, with 40 being in Latin America. The first city on the list that is not in the continent is Cape Town in South Africa, ranked 27th.
Not much has changed on the top of the ranking since the previous year. With a rate of 169 intentional homicides per 100,000 inhabitants (ten more than in 2011), the Honduran city of San Pedro Sula was declared the most violent city in the world for a second year in a row. The city of Acapulco, Mexico, came in second with a rate of 143 murders per 100,000 inhabitants, followed by the Venezuelan capital, Caracas, with a rate of 119.
The report states that “a worsening of public safety and an increase in violence” has occurred in the last few years in countries like Honduras, Venezuela, and Mexico.
Indeed, despite a Mexican city (Ciudad Juárez, in the state of Chihuahua) having been displaced from the top position by San Pedro Sula, the country still has three cities in the top ten, and the violence unleashed in the last few years as consequence of the ‘war on drugs’ is notorious.

Honduran factory worker murdered in San Pedro Sula in 2010 (photo by Globovisión)
The behaviour of various government authorities in Mexico does not inspire confidence in official figures, since there are large amounts of conflicting data. For example, back in 2010 the governor of Chihuahua stated that there were around 4,000 homicides in his state, while the Attorney General offered two other numbers: 5,836 and 7,209. The final figure published by the National Institute of Statistics, Geography and Informatics (INEGI) in December 2011 was 6,421 intentional homicides. With such conflicting information, it is difficult to know for sure what is the real number.
The UN officially published that there were 20,585 homicides in the entire country of Mexico for 2010. In November 2011, INEGI’s researchers noted that this number was inaccurate and should be in fact 38% higher. In their opinion, the mistake was induced by Mexican authorities, who were trying to make the country appear safer than it is.
A similar accusation was levelled at Honduran authorities by Seguridad, Justicia y Paz, who stated in their report the difficulties they found to obtain official information. “We would not be surprised if this lack of information by official sources had the purpose to try and hide the reality of the large cities in the country which is, today, the most violent in the world,” they said.
There is general consensus among sociologists and criminologists regarding the causes of crime in our region. Peruvian political analyst Carlos Basombrío explains: “These factors include rapid, large-scale urbanisation that is incapable of sustaining basic services; extreme inequalities between rich and poor; a culture of violence carved from many years of internal wars; poverty, exclusion, and lack of opportunity for young people; police abuse, corruption, and inefficacy; and the unimpeded availability of guns, drugs, and alcohol, including an overwhelming presence in many cities of small-scale drug trafficking.”
Killing the Watchdogs
Not even the individuals who spread the word to the world are safe. ‘Watchdogs’, who investigate and report from the most dangerous zones of our planet, are willing to risk their own lives just ‘to get the story’. This seems to be especially true in Latin America: according to a recent report by UNESCO, Honduras has the world’s highest number of journalists assassinated per capita.
Since the 2009 coup, Honduras has been one of the Western hemisphere’s most dangerous countries for journalists, with 26 journalists killed in the last four years, according to US-based Freedom House. Their report, published earlier this year, states that: “Harassment against broadcasting outlets has included assaults, threats, blocked transmissions, and power outages.”
Freedom House considers Honduras “to have a culture of impunity, where people who attack journalists are not actively brought to justice.” Many Honduran journalists fear the violence that has been (and is still being) carried out is approved by the government, the 2012 Freedom of the Press report on Honduras stated.
Mexico is not far behind on the ranking. According to a report by the Mexican Centre of Social Communication from 2010, it is the third most dangerous country to exercise the profession.
Is Argentina Becoming Less Dangerous?
Despite the region’s overall danger, it is somewhat of a relief to know that Argentina is getting safer. At least according to official criminal rates.
The Buenos Aires Province’s Ministry of Security stated that overall reported crime in the Province has dropped 5.67%. In the first quarter of 2010, there were 171,342 reported crimes, and in the first quarter of 2011, there were 161,620. The types of crimes included are generally violent ones, such as murder, rape, kidnapping, and theft.

Supreme Court judge Eugenio Zaffaroni (photo by departamentjusticia on Flickr)
“Argentina has gone through some serious situations of social and institutional violence, but currently does not have an alarming crime record, comparing it to the region,” says Supreme Court judge Eugenio Zaffaroni.
According to the latest available data, from 2009, Argentina recorded a murder rate of 5.5 per 100,000 inhabitants – considerably less than the average continental rate of 15.6, as published in the ‘Global Study on Homicide 2011′, prepared by the UN Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC). The same report states that the homicide rate in the Americas “more than doubles the world average (6.9), while with the rate of 17.4 per 100,000 inhabitants, Africa is the continent with the highest rate.”
Nilda Garré, then minister of security, spoke about criminality in Argentina confidently: “According to the UN data, Argentina is well bellow other Latin American countries with regards to homicides.”
For a complete understanding of the UN’s research, it is important to point out that the 2009 study did not include murders in Buenos Aires Province. In 2008, 45% of all the country’s homicides happened in this province, so the results could lose some of its representation.
Even so, Buenos Aires did not make it to the top 50 most dangerous cities. In fact, the homicide rate for the Argentine capital, according to a study by the Supreme Court’s Research Institute, is well below the last city on the list – Barranquilla, Colombia. While in Buenos Aires the rate is 6.57 homicides per 100,000 inhabitants, in Barranquilla it is 29.41.
“If we compare the security situation of Argentina in 2009 with Venezuela, Brazil, and Mexico, the murder rate is much lower. However, when we compare it with other countries in the region, the differences are not so clear. Peru, Chile, and Uruguay do not have very different rates from those observed in Argentina,” explains Lucía Freira, analyst at the Crimes Research Laboratory of the Torcuato Di Tella University.
Despite the hard data, Argentina was still listed between the countries where residents are the least likely to feel safe walking alone at night. It hit 16th place, with Venezuelans and South Africans taking the top spots.
Two thirds of the world’s adult population (67%) feels safe walking alone at night in the area where they live. A figure that rose sharply since the global financial crisis began in 2008. “That is good news for global recovery, because public perceptions of physical security and social order are prerequisites for healthy economic activity. Widespread fears of bodily harm discourage people from venturing out to buy and sell in marketplace, for example, or taking jobs that require them to stay out after dark,” stated Steve Crabtree of Gallup.
Dealing with Criminality in Latin America
Crime and street violence, while prevalent in most parts of the world, are still considered an extreme and intractable problem in Latin America. And there is no visible sign of criminal rates lowering.

Political analyst Carlos Basombrío.
Numerous human rights violations occur as a consequence of efforts to combat crime, including police brutality, restrictive laws that curtail civil liberties, and the militarisation of the public order. Basombrío states: “Because the police in Latin America suffers from lack of training, scarce resources, and, in some instances, complicity with criminals, they frequently abuse and sometimes kill suspects. They almost always enjoy impunity from these acts because many segments of the public welcome such behaviour as means of promoting a safer environment.”
One of the most striking things about security issues in Latin America is the level of interconnectivity that can be found at every level.
“There is no doubt that keeping pace with the sophisticated and transnational nature of criminal organisations will require a sophisticated and transnational strategy – more time consuming, and complex for all actors involved in combating them,” said Maninder Gill, sector manager of the Social Development Department of the Latin America and Caribbean Region with the World Bank.
Addressing the problem of crime, as it affects people’s everyday life, is an enormous challenge for human rights advocates across Latin America, and even more so to defend their right to a secure environment. As Basombrío argues: “The issue of crime presents human rights advocates with challenges that must be resolved, if we are to build legitimacy for human rights principles.”
And that process – if it is ever fully completed – will be extremely long. For those living in or visiting the continent, the best advice is to exercise a greater degree of caution. For when it comes to avoiding crime, you can never be too careful.
How safe do porteños feel in the streets of their city? Click here to find out.
Lead image by Rodrigo Gómez Sanz on Flickr.