Arguably one of the most important announcements to come out of the recent Summit of the Americas, next week on 15th May the United States and Colombia will officially enter into a free trade agreement.
Colombian politicians have named the move a “win-win situation” and a “unique opportunity” for the country. The new agreement aims to bring economic prosperity to Colombia, getting national products into the international market and increasing foreign investment, as well as producing an estimated 500,000 new jobs.
The agreement between the countries has generated controversy, however. At the centre of the debate lies the complaint that union violence, which is rife in Colombia and which was supposed to be eradicated before the agreement came into place, has not yet been dealt with.
How do Argentines feel about free trade with countries like the US? What are the pros and cons of free trade in the Latin American region? Should Argentina relax its own import restrictions and follow Colombia’s footsteps? The Argentina Independent hit the streets of Buenos Aires to find out.
Photos by Natasha Ali
Marcelo Cerdi, 44, Teacher, San Isidro
Simply put, I’m in favour of the economic policy that we have in place currently here in Argentina. I think it’s good that we have more restrictions on goods that we import, and with a bigger emphasis on national products. I pretty much agree with what they’re doing in that respect. I think that the methods they are using suit the country that we’re living in. This is a country that has a lot of pending issues. More than anything, I believe in politics that integrate the whole of Latin America; by that I mean that certain countries should complement each other economically. I think this is the direction we should be going in. The development of this country has been stunted because of economic and political policies that weren’t necessarily the most favourable option for growth and I think that’s the direction in which our policies should be heading.
Maria del Carmen Diambrosis, 52, Teacher, Vicente Lopez
It seems to me that every country in the whole of Latin America needs to be more unified economically; there should be one Latin American economy and trade. We need to now be more careful about what enters the country in terms of imports, because after the Menem years in the 90s, we saw that the economic policies essentially closed up industries. Nowadays, we have been left with normal jobs, teaching, driving taxis, and we can’t compete with big economies like China and what comes in to our country from those countries. There needs to be a common Latin American market, with all the Latin American countries working together, and not with the US. If there was a common market, it would generate competition. It seems to me that it would mean that we could compete economically with the big players, the imperialists.
Jose Bengler, 37, Artisan Worker, Palermo
I’m not an expert on this, but there are some things that I can see anyway. I know that, for example, Argentina and the Argentine state have produced certain restrictions on products that are imported. For me, it seems like a good idea that governments are regulating the economy, that not everything is free or open in the market. It seems like a good idea, a good decision, to have some amount of restriction. In terms of something like Colombia agreeing to free trade, it seems to me, while they can open their doors to trade without restrictions with other countries, there should still be some measures to protect the country’s own products, to protect the work that is done by the people. To me that’s very important.
Vincent Nilesi, 42, Engineer, Palermo
I don’t know a whole load about the issue of free trade but I’m aware that certain agreements like this one between the US and Colombia exist. I work in [the production] industry, so I’m aware of difficulties caused by the economic policies this country has adopted. I am faced with certain problems that exist because of tighter restrictions in terms of trade, with material that we import, and use to make products for example. These tougher import restrictions generate a lot of problems. Because of this, I think we should be much more open in terms of trade between countries. Being more open to the idea of free trade is a good idea: these harsh restrictions are nationalist, not in the way we may know it, but it’s a nationalism that affects local companies through its taxes.
Yanet Capalbo, 19, Cadet, Villa Lugano
I don’t know much about the subject specifically in terms of the trade agreement between Colombia and the US. Free trade is almost like neo-liberalism, it’s a really liberal economic idea. But apart from what it could do economically for any country, for me the concept of free trade doesn’t seem like a good idea because of what it can do to the people, how it could affect them. I feel that free trade is especially bad for workers. In the context of big companies and free trade, workers are always left with less.